Quintessence Int 37 (2006), No. 9 28. Aug. 2006
Quintessence Int 37 (2006), No. 9 (28.08.2006)
Page 731-735, PubMed:17017636
Fracture strength of artificially aged 3-unit adhesive fixed partial dentures made of fiber reinforced composites and ceramics: An in vitro study
Kolbeck, Carola / Rosentritt, Martin / Handel, Gerhard
Objective: The aim of this in vitro study was to examine the fracture strength of metal-free 3-unit adhesive fixed partial dentures (AFPDs) bonded to mandibular incisors.
Method and Materials: Extracted human incisors were positioned in pairs in polymethyl methacrylate resin simulating a clinical anterior situation. Their lingual sides were prepared for adhesive retainers with surfaces and finishing lines in enamel. Eight 3-unit AFPDs were made on master casts per material system: Connect/belleGlass (Girrbach), StickNet (StickTech)/Sinfony (3M Espe), and Empress 2 (Ivoclar Vivadent). The dentures were bonded adhesively using the dual-curing system ED Primer/Panavia F (Kuraray Europe) and aged by thermocycling (6,000 3 5¡ãC/55¡ãC H2O; 2 minutes each cycle) and mechanical loading (1.2 3 106 3 20 N with 1.66 Hz) in an artificial oral environment representing a wearing period of 5 years. The fracture strength was determined in a universal testing machine (UTM 1446, Zwick) at a speed of 1 mm/min, applying the load buccoincisally on the pontics. The different forms of failure were described optically. Medians (25th/75th percentiles) of the fracture results were calculated. Statistical analysis was performed using Mann-Whitney U and Kruskal-Wallis tests (P ¡Ü .05).
Results: Five StickNet/Sinfony AFPDs and 7 Empress 2 restorations failed in the artificial oral environment. The remaining Empress 2 dentures showed the highest medians of fracture forces (339 [200/506] N) compared to Connect/belleGlass (257 [242/310] N) and StickNet/Sinfony (256 [204/347] N). Statistical comparisons showed no significant differences.
Conclusion: Only Connect/belleGlass and Empress 2 showed sufficient resistance against mastication forces.
Keywords: fixed partial denture, fracture strength, metal free, minimally invasive